My Strongest Evidence

Worksheet Description

The “My Strongest Evidence” worksheet is a graphical organizer designed to help students focus on identifying and reflecting on the most compelling piece of evidence that supports their argumentative claim. In the central circle, students are instructed to write down the strongest evidence they have found. Surrounding this central idea are boxes labeled “So What?” where students must articulate the significance of this evidence, including its importance and implications, which helps them to delve deeper into the reasoning behind their argument.

This worksheet is teaching students to not only select robust evidence to support their claims but also to consider and explain the relevance of that evidence to their argument. By filling out the “So What?” sections, students practice justifying why their chosen evidence is persuasive and what it contributes to their overall argument. This exercise encourages critical thinking, as students must analyze and articulate the impact of their evidence beyond its surface value. The goal is to enhance their ability to construct well-substantiated arguments that are convincing and reflective of deeper analytical skills.