Which Is Stronger?

Worksheet Description

This worksheet focuses on the comparative strength of deductive versus inductive reasoning. It presents a single, open-ended question asking which form of reasoning is stronger and requires the respondent to justify their position. The format of the worksheet is designed to encourage critical thinking and to allow for an extended written response. By not suggesting a right or wrong answer, the worksheet prompts students to reflect deeply on the nature of reasoning itself.

The worksheet is teaching students to engage with and understand the fundamental differences between deductive and inductive reasoning. It challenges them to consider the merits and limitations of each reasoning approach and to articulate their thoughts coherently. The task encourages students to draw on their knowledge of logic and argumentation and to practice the skill of constructing a well-reasoned, persuasive argument. This exercise is aimed at developing students’ analytical writing abilities and deepening their philosophical understanding of reasoning methods.