Credibility of Sources

Worksheet Description

This Argumentation worksheet is focused on assessing the credibility of sources used when gathering evidence for an argument. It provides a structured table for students to list their sources and evaluate them based on six criteria: authority, objectivity, authenticity, relevance, timeliness, and efficiency. By filling out this table, students are encouraged to critically analyze the quality of their research materials before deciding to include them as evidence in their arguments. This methodical approach is key in teaching students to discern the trustworthiness and validity of information.

The worksheet is designed to teach students how to critically evaluate information sources for their argumentative essays or debates. It helps them understand that not all sources are created equal and that a source’s credibility can significantly impact the strength of their argument. The criteria listed in the worksheet equip students with a framework for considering various aspects of a source’s reliability. By completing this exercise, students learn to be discerning researchers, which is an essential skill for academic success and responsible citizenship.